Are there nonstop flights from New York (JFK) to Columbus (CMH)?

Yes. American Eagle (airline brand), Delta Connection fly this route. Flight time is about 1h 25m.

What is the fastest connection from New York (JFK) to Columbus (CMH)?

via Washington ≈ 2h, via Washington ≈ 2h 1m, via Hartford ≈ 2h 14m (estimated flying time, excluding layovers).

from 12,000 JAL miles (economy, one way, based on the published award charts).

John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK) to John Glenn Columbus International Airport (CMH)・776 km

Nonstop flights available (2 airlines). Flight time about 1h 25m. Nonstop return flights also operate.

With milesJAL 12,000 miles+ (via CLT)Economy, one way, estimate. Tap a connection for miles by cabin.

15 one-stop options, sorted by estimated flying time. Tap one to see the airlines on each leg and booking links.

Times are estimated from distance. Check schedules, frequency and availability with the airline or a booking site.